Tuesday, December 1, 2015

This or That: Lipstick Edition

It's no secret that I love a good lip color. Although I never used to be a huge lipstick junkie, I have grown to love a lot of different kinds. When I was cleaning the other day, I realized I had two lipsticks that were somewhat similar and decided to try both and see which one I preferred.

[caption id="attachment_1116" align="aligncenter" width="674"]featurepic Left: Cutie by TRUE Isaac Mizrahi // Right: Buttercup by Gerard Cosmetics[/caption]

swatches


The two lip colors that I'm comparing in this post are Cutie by TRUE Isaac Mizrahi and Buttercup by Gerard Cosmetics.


Pictured above are the lipsticks side by side as well as the swatches of each. I would say both of these shades fall in the pink/neutral lip category--which I love! I recently purchased Cutie after eyeing it up for quite some time, while I purchased Buttercup this past spring. Later in the post I will share pictures of me wearing each of these shades. But for now, let's start comparing.



Pricing


Let's talk money. When originally purchasing Buttercup in the spring, I bought a bundle--which was 4 for $48. Individually, this shade currently sells for $19.


As for Cutie, this shade retails online for $24. While it is a little more higher priced that it's competitor Buttercup, the next thing I considered was of course the quality.



Quality & Wearability


   cutie2


Although it may be a little higher priced, Cutie offers an opaque pink color. While this is one of the matte shades in the TRUE Isaac Mizrahi line, I wasn't sure if it would last as long on my lips. Needless to say I was surprised and pleased to find out that this lip color holds true to it's description--vivid color that is long lasting! This lipstick can get a bit drying on the lips if you wear it for a couple consecutive days. At least I know when I put it on, it will stay--right?


buttercup2


Buttercup is a cream lipstick that is the perfect pinkish-nude shade. When applying this shade it is definitely creamier and feels smoother on the lip than Cutie. While I'm a big fan of cream lipsticks, I'm not as pleased with the way this lipstick wears. While the shade itself is pretty, it seems like after a while the lipstick looks kind of "cakey" if that makes any sense. It's not necessarily a bad thing, just not something I particularly care for.



So...Cutie or Buttercup?


Both lipsticks and brands offer something different, which is always important to note. I enjoy wearing both of these lipsticks, but if I had to choose a lipstick to recommend, I would choose...


cutielipwinner


...Cutie!!


Before trying Cutie, I probably would have raved about Buttercup. It's not that I have anything necessarily bad to say about Buttercup, however if I want long lasting lipstick that offers great coverage I'm going to choose Cutie for sure. Although the price is a little more expensive, TRUE Isaac Mizrahi definitely did a great job developing the matte shades (Cutie in particular) do to the great quality of the product.


While Gerard Cosmetics is a more well known brand, I would highly recommend to give TRUE Isaac Mizrahi
a try.  ♥

No comments:

Post a Comment